Wednesday, January 20, 2010

If a tree fell in a forest and there was no one to hear it. Would the squirrels?

I mean you can't really ask them or could you?If a tree fell in a forest and there was no one to hear it. Would the squirrels?
of course they hear it...squirrels know all!!!If a tree fell in a forest and there was no one to hear it. Would the squirrels?
Yeah, they would! I never would have come up with this. :]
Well actually, by virtue of the fact that I live mostly in a very rural area in the Rocky Mountains I have had the privilege of seeing a tree crash down in the woods. I was standing on the porch overlooking the river when I heard this major crackling, snapping and crashing sounds. I looked across the river to see this huge cottonwood tree just fall, collapse like. Afterwords, besides the rushing river it was dead silent.


But if you want to, go ahead and ask the squirrels!
You could secretly videotape their reactions...
A squirrel is one that would hear it in the first place if there was a squirrel there.
The Squirrel would know!
Who knows?
By saying that there was noone to hear it, you are inferring that the squirels are also absent. So, the answer is no.
the squirrel might to stupid to even notice, he might just hear a loud noise and run away...
if the squirrels were there at the time
They would know, because they can hear...and depending on how long and big is the tree they would also feel the impact..
They would hear it and react to it. Maybe run away, that's how you would know they heard it. I'm sure if you timed their reaction to the fall you could tell if they are reacting to the sound it makes or the vibration it makes. I'd say they are reacting to the sound first though since that's the first wave that will travel out from the fall.
All laws of physics say a tree would make a sound if no one was around to hear it. So yes, it would.
You could ask, but could you hear their response?





I don't think squirrel's ears stop working when people aren't around.
If one was close by, yes i think they'd know.

No comments:

Post a Comment